|
| Premium Access Members - The Eagle |
|
Editor’s Note: This article is part of a special free series. These articles will provide some of the history of THE EAGLE and give our members a taste of this new Premium Access department at WhatTheyThink.com. Please help us welcome THE EAGLE and their co-publishers, Steve Aranoff and Robert FitzPatrick. Contact Steve at Steve@arttex.com, or Robert at robertf765@aol.com Commentary Freedom of the Press in the Printing Industry: The Eagle's Odyssey (Part 3 of a Series) January 22, 2003 -- Open Bars and Lawyer Letters In the early 1980s, a multi-association management company ran the graphic arts dealer trade association. The annual meetings of the dealer group were officially planned each year by a manufacturer. The most active members were the manufacturers. Ostensibly this organization provided a forum where channel issues, vital to all the suppliers' economic viability, could be openly and frankly considered in a collegial setting. Yet the industry's restrictive "information culture" was largely preventing this. In place of candid dialogue a culture of enforced conviviality had grown up. Meetings were treated as annual - paid and tax deductible - holidays by larger dealers and manufacturer managers. Key factors for conference site selections were golf courses and luxury accommodations. Conference fees covered open bars each evening. A good time was had by all. However, little of substance regarding channel relations was discussed. While they were plotting to form an alternative, dealer-led trade group, many of the dealers attended the regularly scheduled annual meeting of the existing group – held in Hawaii. They had planned to raise important issues about the channel policies of a major vendor. When they arrived, however, association managers handed out copies of an attorney letter advising that such discussion would likely be illegal and therefore not sanctioned by the organization. No effort was made to broach the subject - which was far wider than one vendor - in a legal manner. With nothing to talk about, everyone decided to have a drink, attend the luau and play golf. The impetus for a dealer-only organization surged forward. Mug Shots on the Wall The first dealer-led association was launched in 1983, and THE EAGLE was made the official journal of the organization. An advocacy attorney was hired whose job was to enable discussion of sensitive issues not warn against it. A "model dealers contract" was drawn up and voted on. Resolutions for reform of the channel were adopted and "line committees" were formed which undertook to have direct meetings with key manufacturers. The meetings were a true breakthrough for the dealer community. Finally, under the auspices of their own organization, the dealers could bring issues to the table that affected their ability to be viable, remain loyal to their vendors and to serve their customers. Ominously, some dealers chose not to participate, warning that outspoken dealers would eventually pay for their actions. Gallows humor prevailed in which some dealers said a list was being compiled of the recalcitrant members. Indeed, some had heard the association and its leaders, well-known and long established dealers, referred to by manufacturer managers as "radical." The culture of censorship and control was confusing dialogue with disloyalty and questions with confrontation. At the time of the association's formation, Fujifilm of Japan had lost to bankruptcy its one, exclusive dealer in America. It now sought independent dealers across the country to sell Fuji products. Fuji had adopted the new association's model contract, the only company at that time to do so. It offered dealers higher margins. Its products were proven worldwide. Many dealers, understandably, wanted to represent the new line. Globalization had arrived. But many in the industry were unprepared for global markets. Word spread in the channel that taking on the Fuji line - even though all dealers carried multiple and competing lines - would be viewed as a contract violation, punishable by termination. Some of the same dealers who were active in forming the new dealer organization took up Fuji's offer. Most, however, held back in fear for their business lives. The freedom of a dealer to sell whatever lines it chose, a topic that had been silenced in the press and at industry conferences, came to the surface. Restraint of trade was whispered among the dealers. Talk of "disloyalty " and lack of "patriotism" was spoken of by some manufacturers. At this same time, the new dealer association chose to organize a dealer-led trade delegation to Japan to look firsthand at Japanese product opportunities and to talk with Japanese dealers. Fuji (film, plates, proofing), Hamada (printing presses), and Dainippon Screen (graphic arts cameras, scanners and digital imaging equipment) offered to host meetings with the US dealer group. A Japanese trade association in Japan that included Konica and others invited the American group to a special dinner and dialogue. The trip also included attendance at a graphic arts trade show in Hong Kong where still other Asian suppliers would be met. While many dealers expressed initial enthusiasm in participating, as the date for departure drew near, cancellations increased and promised registration forms did not appear. One dealer summed up the growing reluctance to take the trip. "I would love to go, but I don’t want my picture on a tour of a Japanese factory coming back home and put up on a manufacturer's wall like a mug shot." A picture, it was meant, could be a dealership's economic death sentence. (To be continued) Part Four Coming Soon Please offer your feedback. Contact Steve at Steve@arttex.com, or Robert at robertf765@aol.com See more from THE EAGLE  |
 Stephen P. Aranoff is founder and principal of ARTTEX Associates. He has 28 years experience in the development and profitable distribution of printing/digital imaging market products. Managing prepress technology companies from start-up through significant growth, such as Xyvision, Eikonix, Raytheon Graphics, UNDA, and ScanView, he has played a leading role in introducing many first-of-a-kind successful printing industry products. Since 1986, ARTTEX has provided pragmatic business, marketing and sales strategy and implementation consulting to both large and small client companies based upon this successful operating expertise – including bringing off shore products to the domestic market. Well known clients include: Cactus/3M, Dainippon Screen, Heartland Imaging/VieNet, Island Graphics, Kodak, Ricoh, and Scitex, as well as venture capitalists, law firms and startup technology ventures. Since 1995, Mr. Aranoff has specialized in the marketing and distribution of Digital Imaging products, with emphasis on marketplace convergence brought about by the use of powerful off-the-shelf components. Mr. Aranoff also holds a Masters Degrees in Systems Engineering and an MBA Degree, with Distinction, in Sales/Marketing. He often serves as a speaker and forum moderator and for many years, has done so at NAGASA’s Forums. He is also a frequent guest writer for digital imaging publications. Contact Stephen Aranoff at: 25 Canyon Shadows Drive, Sedona, AZ 86336 USA, Tel: (928)282-4173, Cell: (928)300-8757, Fax: (775)254-5768, email: Steve@arttex.com | - | - | - |
 Robert L. FitzPatrick, president of FitzPatrick Management Inc., is an industrial relations consultant, writer, speaker, facilitator, and trade association advisor. He is a nationally recognized analyst of mature industries. His work involves grasping the fundamental economic needs of all parties in the supply chain as well as understanding the dynamics and life cycles of products. Since 1981, Robert FitzPatrick has continuously published THE EAGLE, a unique and influential journal that analyzes technology, manufacturer/ dealer relations and trends in analog and digital product distribution. His articles on the dynamics of mature industries have appeared in trade journals for graphic arts, sanitation supply, automobile parts, office automation, wholesale florist and food processing industries, among others. He has been a featured speaker at dealer conferences for Hewlett Packard, FujiFilm, among other major companies and he has organized international dealer/manufacturer conferences in Antwerp, Belgium and in Guadalajara, Mexico. Consultancy clients of FitzPatrick Management include Fuji Photo, DuPont, Lastra S.p.a., Anchor Chemistry, AB Dick, #1 Network, London Litho, Heartland Imaging, VieNet.com, among others. He was a consultant and featured speaker at the meetings of Food Industries Suppliers Association (FISA) four consecutive years. In 1997, Robert FitzPatrick co-authored and published the first book to expose and critique the multi-level marketing model of sales and distribution. Entitled, False Profits, this book is available in bookstores nationwide or from the publisher at web site www.falseprofits.com. He has served as Expert Witness in various cases involving pyramid scheme fraud perpetrated against independent distributors. Contact Robert FitzPatrick at 1522 Lilac Rd., Charlotte, NC 28209 USA. Tel.: (704) 334-2047, Fax: (704) 334-0220, Email: robertf765@aol.com. |
WTT Full Disclosure Statement: Unless otherwise noted, the author has no current business relationship with any of the companies named in this article. The views expressed by our contributing writers are their own and may not reflect those of WhatTheyThink.com. WhatTheyThink.com may have formal business dealings with companies named in Premium Access articles. However, these relationships play no role in the editorial content at this site. See our complete editorial policy by clicking here. |
Latest Videos
manroland President & CEO Vince Lapinski at Print09 Media Days-
This Week with Frank Romano: Frank takes a ride on Amtrak, reviews "Connecting the Dots", and shows us the orginal Grand Central Station - Ralph Nappi, President of GASC, talks about the Print09 Stimulus Package
Economics and Research Center
Blog
- Should Printers Watch the Stock Market for an Upturn Clue? (Jul 1)
- One Recovery Indicator Breaks to the Upside but Three Decline (Jun 3)
- Missing Any Opportunities? (May 27)
- Where Does Print Media Fit? It's Up to Us. (May 20)
Industry Snapshot
The Industry Snapshot is a collection of regularly updated industry data. The snapshot includes Industry Capacity, Capacity utilization, Printing Shipments, employment, and other and various measures of business activity.
Audio Chart
Net new businesses, 12-month moving average - 06/29- Change in Newspaper Advertising Revenue - 06/22
- Current Dollar/Year Change in Corporate Cash Flow - 06/15
- AIGA Designer Confidence Index - 06/08
- Change in Real GDP, CPI-adjusted Print Shipments & Paper Shipments - 06/01
- Rate of Change in Employment in Content Creation Segments - 05/25
- Change in Total Employment, March vs. April 1990-2009 - 05/18
- Thousands of Net New Businesses Per Month - 05/11
- Change in Real US GDP on a Year/Year Basis - 05/04
- Percentage of Printers Increasing Participation in Local Business Events, Trade Shows - 04/27
- Percentage of Printers Using Direct Mail Promotional Campaigns to Promote Business - 04/20
- Weekly Audio Chart Archive »
Popular Stories from Last Week
(10) Sales Comp study
(9) Bye Bye Kodachrome
(8) Video: Ricoh's Carl Joachim
(7) Your Digital Press Operators
(6) Prism award to Joshi
(5) MOD-PAC exits print
(4) Talking to the CMO
(3) Bankruptcy and print
(2) Vistaprint new strategy
(1) Former RRD CEO to lead Quebecor
Get 2 Weeks FreeBecome a Premium Member and get your first two weeks free. No obligations. Join Today » |
|||
|
Log in or register to access your WhatTheyThink Account Help & Member Center |
About |
WhatTheyThink Services |
WhatTheyThink Network |
Copyright © 2009 WhatTheyThink. All Rights Reserved